ABC has officially greenlit American Idol for Season 24, marking its ninth season since the show’s revival on the network—and fans are already buzzing. But the good news comes with a big question mark: Will Carrie Underwood be back on the judges’ panel?
The announcement was made on Instagram with a post that read, “Dim the lights… here we go. #AmericanIdol is coming back for another season!”—a nod to host Ryan Seacrest’s iconic line before elimination results are revealed. The network also confirmed that virtual auditions are now open, continuing the show’s nationwide search for the next big star.
Carrie Underwood joined Idol this past season, stepping in for longtime judge Katy Perry. Her addition brought excitement—and some mixed reactions. While many fans loved seeing the country superstar back where it all began, others felt this season’s judging panel—Carrie, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—was a little too soft. Critics say the judges offered mostly praise and lacked the tough love that used to define the show.
Behind the scenes, sources say Carrie has struggled with the judging role, especially when it comes to sending contestants home. Insiders report she’s found it tough to deliver negative feedback and worries about being seen as harsh. As a result, there’s growing speculation she may choose not to return for the next season.
Still, fans are holding out hope. After ABC’s announcement, social media lit up with comments begging for Carrie, Luke, and Lionel to return, showing that many viewers have embraced the current panel despite the pushback.
Season 23 has delivered what fans have come to expect—emotional backstories, rising talent, and powerful performances from finalists like Jamal Roberts, Breanna Nix, and John Foster. While the show may not be churning out superstars on the level of Carrie Underwood or Kelly Clarkson these days, it remains a go-to platform for discovering fresh talent and telling inspiring stories.
As the season finale approaches, the spotlight is still firmly on the contestants’ growth and passion for music. And that, after all, is what American Idol has always been about.
Whether Carrie returns or not, the show’s renewal makes one thing clear: American Idol is still a fan favorite, evolving with the times while staying true to its roots. And as one group of hopefuls sings their way into America’s hearts, the legacy of the show—and the dream it represents—continues strong.
