Reality TV is known for its jaw-dropping moments, but few compare to Josh Krajcik’s unforgettable audition on The X Factor back in 2011. What started out as a light, almost comical intro from a chill burrito shop worker from Ohio quickly turned into one of the show’s most iconic performances.

Josh stepped onto the stage with a relaxed vibe, cracking jokes about his day job and flashing an easy smile. The judges and audience chuckled, likely expecting something fun but forgettable. Then he dropped his song choice: Etta James’ powerhouse ballad “At Last.” That’s when the atmosphere changed. Simon Cowell raised an eyebrow, clearly doubtful. This was about to get interesting…